The CeruleanSt. Croix · U.S. Virgin Islands
2008-01-28 Tague Bay St. Croix

St. Croix vs. St. Thomas vs. St. John

Three U.S. islands and no passport. Here is what each one does best, and who it suits.

Photo: Jpheym Jason P. Heym / Seascape Pool Center Inc. (CC BY-SA 3.0)

St. Croix is the biggest and quietest of the three main USVI islands, with two historic towns, Buck Island and room for a group to spread out. St. Thomas is the busiest, with the most flights, shops and resorts. St. John is mostly national park, reached by ferry. U.S. citizens can visit any of them with no passport, and most first-time visitors pick one by accident, usually the one with the most flights. We host guests on St. Croix's East End, so we have a favorite, and below is what each island does best: beaches, snorkeling, food, cost, flights and the ways across.

The short answer

For the most nonstop flights, the biggest choice of restaurants and shops, large resorts and the energy of a working cruise port, choose St. Thomas. For a national park with beaches in it, reached by ferry from St. Thomas, choose St. John. For the biggest of the three, with a pair of historic towns, farms and rum distilleries, quiet beaches, a wall dive that starts from the sand, and your own house on the water, choose St. Croix.

The differences are structural, not marketing. The northern two sit close together, a 15-to-20-minute ferry apart, and share one airport. St. Croix sits alone about 40 miles to the south, with its own airport, its own towns and its own economy. St. Croix covers 84 square miles, St. Thomas 32 and St. John about 20. The 2020 census put St. Croix at 41,004 people, St. Thomas at 42,261 and St. John at 3,881, which works out to roughly 490 people per square mile on St. Croix against about 1,320 on St. Thomas. That single ratio explains most of what follows.

St. Thomas leads on flights, shopping, restaurant choice, nightlife, and quick trips to St. John or the BVI. St. John leads on the park, Trunk Bay and hiking. St. Croix leads on space, Buck Island, diving, quiet and, in our experience, the most house for the money when a big group travels together.

84 sq miSt. Croix
32 sq miSt. Thomas
20 sq miSt. John
40 milesSea between
25 minSeaplane

Comparing them two at a time

Most people are really choosing between two, so here is each pair on its own.

St. Croix vs. St. Thomas

This is the choice between a big, spread-out island and a small, busy one. St. Croix is more than double the size of St. Thomas and holds about the same number of people, so its roads, beaches and towns feel roomier. You will want a rental car. St. Thomas packs its restaurants, shops and resorts into less space, so you can do more without one, and its flights run from more cities. Pick St. Croix for a house on the water and a week of exploring. Pick St. Thomas for a resort, a short break or a place to be near the action.

St. Croix vs. St. John

These two are both quieter choices, in different ways. St. John is small and green, about 60 percent national park, with trails and beaches you can reach from Cruz Bay, and you arrive by ferry. St. Croix is about four times the size, with working towns, farms, rum distilleries and its own airport. Pick St. John if you are going for the national park. Pick St. Croix if you want more to see over a full week, direct flights, and room for a large group under one roof.

St. Thomas vs. St. John

These two are close neighbors, 15 to 20 minutes apart by ferry, so plenty of people do both. St. Thomas is the base with the airport, the resorts and the nightlife. St. John is the place you go for the day, or stay on for a slower week. If you only have a long weekend, stay on St. Thomas and take the ferry over for a day at the beach.

Three islands, one flag: the map

Look at the territory on a map and the arrangement is obvious. The two northern islands are hills in a cluster of hills, the western end of a chain that continues east as the British Virgin Islands. St. Croix is a separate, bigger, flatter island out in the Caribbean Sea, some 40 miles from St. Thomas and about 65 miles from Puerto Rico. Nobody swims that gap. You cross it by seaplane, by ferry, or by a short airport-to-airport flight, and the crossing is the first thing to understand about choosing between them.

At 84 square miles, St. Croix is the territory's biggest island, about 22 miles long and 7 wide at its widest. Mount Eagle tops out at 1,165 feet, yet much of the land is gently rolling old cane country. The northwest corner is green and wooded, and the East End is dry and sunny, all low hills and sea grape out to Point Udall, billed as the country's easternmost point. Our villa sits on that sunny end, on its own bay.

St. Thomas is 32 square miles and steep. Crown Mountain rises 1,555 feet on an island a third the size of St. Croix, so the roads climb and switch back, the views are the selling point, and the flat land is mostly the harbor front around Charlotte Amalie. Cyril E. King Airport lies two miles west of downtown. St. John, about 20 square miles, is hilly as well and has no airport at all; you arrive by ferry, mostly from Red Hook at St. Thomas's east end into Cruz Bay, and roughly 60 percent of what you see is Virgin Islands National Park.

The practical consequence: from the northern pair you can be on three islands in a day. On St. Croix you are on one island, and it is big enough that a week is not enough to drive all of it. Which of those sounds like a holiday to you is most of the decision.

St Croix NASA
St. Croix from space: the territory's biggest island, out on its own some 40 miles from its two neighbors. Photo: NASA (Public domain)

Character: the port, the park, and the place

St. Thomas is the port. Charlotte Amalie was founded by the Danes in 1666 as Taphus (Danish for "beer house"), renamed in 1691 for the queen of Christian V, and it has been the trading harbor of these islands ever since. Today it is the territorial capital and the largest town in the USVI, at 8,194 people, and a busy stop for cruise ships.

Main Street, the old Dronningens Gade, is lined with shops, many of them selling jewelry. On a multi-ship day the downtown is lively by mid-morning, and on a no-ship day it is a handsome, hilly harbor town.

St. John is the park. In 1956 Laurance Rockefeller's Jackson Hole Preserve gave its land on the island to the National Park Service on condition that it be protected from development, and Virgin Islands National Park was established that August. About 60 percent of the island is park today, and the census counts 3,881 residents. There is no airport, no cruise pier, and not much flat ground.

St. Croix is the place: the island that runs on its own life rather than on the visitor economy. At its height it ran more than 150 sugar mills and ranked among the richest sugar islands in the region, and the landscape still shows it, with estate ruins, stone windmill towers, and cattle in the fields.

It has two historic towns rather than one, Frederiksted and Christiansted, the old colonial capital, which is where the nickname "Twin City" comes from. Cruzan Rum and the Captain Morgan distillery both make rum here. Frederiksted's pier received three to eight cruise ships a month in 2023-24, so on most days no ship is in port at all, and the harbor in Christiansted holds little more than small boats, Buck Island trips and the seaplane. People here go to the farmers' market and to Agrifest, and visitors are welcome to come along.

Charlotte Amalie Harbor Seaplane Base
Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas: founded by the Danes in 1666, the territory's capital and a busy cruise port. Photo: LittleT889 (CC BY 4.0)

The comparison table

Here are all three in one grid. Read the row that matters most to you first. For most groups it is either "cruise ships" or "airport."

FactorSt. CroixSt. ThomasSt. John
Size84 sq mi, the largest32 sq miAbout 20 sq mi
Population (2020)41,00442,2613,881
People per sq miRoughly 490Roughly 1,320Roughly 200
Main townChristiansted and FrederikstedCharlotte Amalie, the territorial capitalCruz Bay
FeelAgricultural, historic, quietSteep harbor city, cruise port, resortsA national park with a small town
Cruise ships3 to 8 a month at Frederiksted (2023-24)A busy cruise portNone dock, day-trippers arrive by ferry
Signature beachBuck Island's Turtle Beach and the East End baysMagens Bay, about $7 to enterTrunk Bay, $5 for ages 16 and up
Signature snorkelBuck Island's marked underwater trail (by boat)Beach snorkeling off the bays, boat trips to St. JohnTrunk Bay's underwater trail, from the beach
AirportSTX: Miami all year, Newark on Saturdays, and Charlotte, Atlanta and Chicago in seasonSTT: the busiest in the USVI, a dozen-plus mainland citiesNone, ferry from St. Thomas
NightlifeA few good bars, early nightsThe most bars and restaurantsCruz Bay bars, small and early
Best forFamilies, groups, divers, history, spaceShopping, flights, resorts, first-timersHikers, park lovers, couples

"People per square mile" is our arithmetic from the census figures above: St. Thomas fits about the same number of people as St. Croix into a third of the land. If flights decide your trip, jump to the section on airports below. If space decides it, keep going.

Beaches, side by side

St. Thomas has the more famous single beach. Magens Bay is a crescent of sand nearly three quarters of a mile long on the island's north shore, given in 1946 by the financier Arthur S. Fairchild to the people of the two islands, whose 56-acre gift came with conditions that no hotel and no casino ever be built there and that the beach carry his family name.

It is run by the Magens Bay Authority, which charges visitors over 12 about $7 and provides lifeguards, showers, sheds and rentals. About 300,000 people a year go, and it is busiest on cruise days. It is a lovely, organized beach.

St. John has the postcard. Trunk Bay, inside the national park, is the beach on the territory's brochures, and the National Park Service charges an amenity fee of $5 per person aged 16 and up from sunrise to sunset, by card or phone only since October 1, 2026, for a beach whose snorkel trail is marked underwater. The park itself charges nothing to enter. Trunk Bay is beautiful in exactly the way the photographs promise, and it is busiest on ship days.

St. Croix has no single beach with a gate and a brand. It has a list. Sandy Point in the southwest, a national wildlife refuge with the territory's longest beach (open weekends only, and closed in turtle nesting season). Cane Bay and the north shore, where the reef wall starts a swim from the sand. Rainbow Beach and the Frederiksted strand on the calm west coast. Buck Island's Turtle Beach, reached by boat. And the East End bays: Jack's and Isaac's on foot, Grapetree, Shoys, Teague, and the beach below the villa, with its reef just out front. Most of them, most days, hold a handful of people or none.

St. John's beaches as a set are hard to beat for looks. St. Thomas's best beach is a well-run public park. St. Croix's beaches are more numerous and more varied, with fewer people on them, and the public ones charge no admission. One famous crescent with a lifeguard: go north. A different, quiet bay every day: go south.

StJohnTrunkBay
Trunk Bay on St. John, inside the national park: the beach on the territory's postcards, and the one with a $5 gate. Photo: Ben Whitney (Public domain)

Snorkeling and diving: Buck Island vs. Trunk Bay

Both islands' signature snorkels are marked underwater trails, and they are different experiences. Trunk Bay's trail is a walk-in: you pay the $5 fee, wade off the beach, and follow markers along the reef inside the bay. It is easy, family-friendly and often described as the first of its kind, and it is popular for exactly those reasons.

Buck Island's trail runs through the lagoon of a national monument roughly 1.5 miles offshore. President Kennedy created the monument in 1961, and since 2001 no fishing has been allowed. You reach it only by an authorized boat (40 to 90 minutes, from town or an East End marina), swim it in small groups with a guide, and finish with an hour on Turtle Beach, and you pay no entrance fee. The boats and rules are in our guide to Buck Island.

For divers the comparison stops being close. St. Croix has the thing the other two do not: a wall you reach on foot from the sand. At Cane Bay you swim out a little way from the sand and the wall starts, dropping toward the Puerto Rico Trench. That makes the north shore a place to dive from the beach instead of from a boat, and the wall gets its own guide. Divers also fly in for night dives under Frederiksted's pier. The two northern islands have good diving too, mostly from boats.

Off the beach, St. Croix's East End is reef country. The reef sits right off the villa's beach, Jack's and Isaac's bays are protected shoreline, and a marine park wraps the whole tip. St. Thomas's beach snorkeling is fine; St. John's, at Trunk Bay and along the park shoreline, is very good and reachable on foot. If snorkeling is the trip, St. John and St. Croix both beat St. Thomas; if diving is the trip, St. Croix wins.

BuckIslandReedNM
Buck Island lies about 1.5 miles offshore to the northeast, with a marked underwater trail, Turtle Beach and no entrance fee. Photo: Wikimedia user Russavia (Public domain)
Turquoise bay framed by the villa's arched veranda
The Cerulean

Try St. Croix from the villa

Stay above the East End water in one of five bedrooms, with Buck Island and Christiansted close by. See the open weeks.

Sleeps 12 · 4.75 ★ on Airbnb · rates by season

History and culture, island by island

All three islands spent close to two centuries under Denmark and have been American since 1917, when Denmark's sale took effect. Their histories then diverge, and the divergence is a good guide to what each island feels like now.

St. Thomas was always the harbor: Charlotte Amalie grew from a 1666 tavern settlement into the trading port of the Danish colony, and its old core still holds Fort Christian, the oldest standing structure in the Virgin Islands archipelago; the 17th-century tower called Blackbeard's Castle (Skytsborg to the Danes), a National Historic Landmark; the 99 Steps up the hill; and a synagogue that is the second oldest in the Western Hemisphere and the oldest under the U.S. flag. It is a maritime, mercantile history, and Main Street's jewelry stores are its direct descendants.

St. Croix was always the plantation. On his second voyage, in November 1493, Columbus's ships stopped at Salt River, the only spot on today's U.S. soil his crews are known to have reached. In 1733 France sold the island to Denmark's West India Company. Christiansted then served as capital of the whole Danish colony, and sugar made the island rich.

Alexander Hamilton clerked in Christiansted as a boy, enslaved people won their freedom at Frederiksted in 1848, and the island changed hands so often that locals talk of its seven flags. The forts, the Scale House, the great house at Whim, the windmill towers across the hills: the landscape explains itself if you drive it slowly.

St. John was a plantation island too, and the park now looks after its ruins: the Annaberg sugar works with a restored windmill, and the Reef Bay Trail, which drops through forest to Taíno rock carvings. Then, in 1956, much of the island became a park, and its modern history is the history of that park.

Living culture follows the same pattern. St. Croix's calendar runs on its own festivals: the Crucian Christmas Festival, Agrifest in February, the mocko jumbies and quelbe bands, Jump Up nights on the Christiansted boardwalk. St. Thomas has more of everything staged for a visitor and a proud, urban Virgin Islands culture underneath it; St. John's is small-town and park-shaped. If history is a reason you travel, St. Croix has the most of it per mile and two whole towns of it.

  1. 1493Columbus reaches Salt River on his second voyage
  2. 1666The Danes found Taphus, the future Charlotte Amalie, on St. Thomas
  3. 1691Taphus is renamed Charlotte Amalie for the queen of Christian V
  4. 1733St. Croix passes from France to Denmark
  5. 1848Enslaved people win emancipation at Frederiksted
  6. 1917All three islands become American after a sale by Denmark
  7. 1946Arthur Fairchild gives Magens Bay to the people of St. Thomas and St. John
  8. 1956Virgin Islands National Park is established on St. John (August 2)
  9. 1961President Kennedy protects Buck Island as a national monument
  10. 2026United starts flying Newark to St. Croix on Saturdays, October 31

Food and drink on the three islands

St. Thomas eats out. It has the deepest restaurant list in the territory, from Frenchtown, the fishing quarter settled by families from Saint-Barthélemy, to the resort restaurants and the harbor-front bars. St. John's dining is concentrated in Cruz Bay and is much smaller; it is good, and it tends to close early. Eating out isn't cheap on any of them, because food is shipped in.

St. Croix cooks. Its restaurant scene is spread between Christiansted's boardwalk and streets and Frederiksted's strand, with a few good places out east and mid-island; our restaurants directory lists the ones we have confirmed open in 2026.

What St. Croix has that the others do not is a food culture that grew out of farming: the Crucian kitchen of fungi, kallaloo, johnnycakes, saltfish and roast pork, the Saturday farm stands, the produce and livestock fair at Agrifest, and the island's two big rum makers, Cruzan and Captain Morgan, both distilling here. It is the island where a private chef will cook a Crucian meal in your kitchen with produce from the Saturday market.

That last point is the practical one for a group. Twelve people eating out twice a day on any of the three islands is a serious line in the budget, and on St. Thomas the temptation to do so is constant because the restaurants are right there. At an East End villa the arithmetic flips. You cook indoors or on the outdoor grill most nights, the groceries directory tells you where the good stores and the fish are, and a chef from our private chefs directory covers the nights you would rather not. Dinner in town, fifteen to twenty minutes away, becomes an occasion.

A couple chasing a different restaurant every night should pick St. Thomas. A group happier with one long table above the sea and an occasional night in town should pick St. Croix. Whichever you choose, check that a place is open before you drive there.

C20230924 121232
St. Croix's Danish era left the island two towns and hundreds of estate ruins; Christiansted was the capital of the Danish colony. Photo: CaptJayRuffins (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Nightlife and shopping

St. Thomas has the most bars, the latest nights and the biggest shopping district in the territory, along Charlotte Amalie's Main Street and the alleys off it. Duty-free rules apply territory-wide, and the higher U.S. allowance for goods bought in the USVI is the same on St. Croix as on St. Thomas (see the numbers in our duty-free guide), but the sheer density of watch, jewelry, liquor and camera stores is a St. Thomas thing, built for the cruise trade.

St. Croix's version is smaller and, to our taste, better. Christiansted's arcaded streets hold a few blocks of jewelry shops, galleries and boutiques, and its nightlife is the boardwalk: a handful of bars on the harbor, live music some nights, and Jump Up, the street festival held four times a year, when the old town shuts to traffic. Frederiksted's waterfront has bars that fill for sunset. Most of it is done by midnight, and on a weeknight earlier, which suits a villa week that starts at sunrise.

St. John's Cruz Bay has a compact bar scene a few minutes' walk from the ferry, and it suits the island: a drink after a hike, dinner, an early night, because tomorrow is another beach. On both St. Croix and St. John, "nightlife" often means the sky. Away from Charlotte Amalie's lights, the East End's night sky is the after-dinner show, and our guests end up on the fire pit terrace.

What a stay costs

We will not quote nightly rates, because they swing by season, by property and by how far ahead you book, and any number we printed would be wrong by the time you read it. What we can describe is the structure of each island's lodging, which is what actually decides your budget.

St. Thomas has the most inventory at every level: large resorts, mid-range hotels, condos and villas, plus hotels at the island's East End near the Red Hook ferry to St. John. St. John's supply is the smallest of the three, mostly villas and a small number of resorts; the small supply and the park's fame set its prices, which is why it is often called the priciest of the three in high season.

St. Croix has fewer large resorts than St. Thomas and more of its beds in villas, small inns and condos, spread over a much bigger island. That structure tends to favor groups: a five-bedroom house sleeping twelve, divided twelve ways, usually compares well against six resort rooms on either of the other islands, and you get a kitchen, a pool and the beach to yourselves.

The rest of the budget behaves the same way on all three islands, with a few differences. Everyone rents a car on St. Croix, because the island is big and there is no useful public transport for visitors; on St. Thomas taxis cover a lot of trips, and on St. John many visitors rent a car for the park roads. Groceries cost more than at home everywhere in the territory. Beach fees are a St. Thomas and St. John line item (Magens Bay about $7, Trunk Bay about $5); St. Croix's public beaches are free.

Island-hopping goes in the budget too: the seaplane is priced like a short flight, and the ferry posts $85 one way, so a family of five crossing and returning spends $850 on the ferry alone. Plan on one good day of it.

The summary: St. Thomas offers the widest range of prices. St. John is generally the priciest per night. St. Croix, for a group willing to cook and drive, tends to deliver the most house and the most privacy per dollar.

Airports and direct flights

Cyril E. King Airport (STT), two miles west of Charlotte Amalie, is the busiest airport in the U.S. Virgin Islands, with about 1.6 million passengers in 2025. St. Croix's airport, STX, had about 527,000, and that helps keep the island quiet.

St. Thomas draws from more cities. Its list includes American from Miami, Charlotte, Dallas, New York JFK and Philadelphia, Delta from Atlanta, with Boston and JFK in season, United from Newark, Houston and Washington Dulles, JetBlue from San Juan and Boston, and Southwest from Baltimore and Orlando. Breeze adds Tampa from December 16, 2026, and Sun Country flies from Minneapolis in season. Airline maps change every season, so treat that as a snapshot.

St. Croix has five mainland routes, and we checked them against the airlines' flights on sale on November 5, 2026. On American you get Miami twice daily this winter, Charlotte (Saturdays, then most days once December 17 arrives) and O'Hare, which starts its winter Saturdays on December 19. Delta's Atlanta flight is Saturday-only until December 19, then appeared on every date we tried through April 6. Saturdays also bring United from Newark, the island's only route to the New York area. Dates and times are on our direct flights page, and the fly-from pages for New York, Charlotte, Philadelphia, Dallas, Houston, Denver, Minneapolis and Milwaukee cover the rest.

What that means in practice: from Miami, Charlotte or Atlanta in high season, the two islands are equally easy. From the Northeast, St. Thomas has more days to choose from, and St. Croix has a Saturday flight from Newark that fits a house rented Saturday to Saturday. From Texas, Philadelphia, Washington and the upper Midwest, St. Thomas has a nonstop and St. Croix is one connection away, or a short Cape Air hop.

Mainland citySt. Thomas (STT)St. Croix (STX)
MiamiAmericanAmerican, twice a day this winter
CharlotteAmericanAmerican, Saturdays and then most days from Dec 17, 2026
AtlantaDeltaDelta, Saturdays and then daily from Dec 19, 2026 into April
Chicago O'HareAmerican and United, seasonalAmerican, Saturdays from Dec 19, 2026, pausing Jan 3 to Feb 12
New York areaUnited from Newark, American and Delta from JFKUnited from Newark, Saturdays
Dallas, Houston, Philadelphia, Washington, Boston, Baltimore, Orlando, MinneapolisNonstops on various carriers, some seasonalChange planes once, usually in Miami, Charlotte or Atlanta
From San JuanJetBlue or Cape AirCape Air, Fly The Whale, and JetBlue from Nov 19, 2026
Between the twoCape Air, about 25 minutesCape Air, about 25 minutes

Getting between the islands: seaplane, ferry, Cape Air

Three ways cross the 40 miles, and one of them is a small joy. Seaborne Airlines flies Twin Otters on floats from the seaport on Christiansted's harbor to Charlotte Amalie's waterfront, which the airline describes as 25 minutes from one downtown to the other. The plane seats 19. You take off from the harbor, cross 40 miles of open sea and land right next to the ferry dock in the center of St. Thomas's capital, so you can spend the day in town with no taxi at all. Bag limits are lower than on a jet.

The ferry is the QE IV, sailing from Gallows Bay in Christiansted to Charlotte Amalie's Blyden terminal. As posted on November 5, 2026, it runs six days a week, every day but Tuesday, with an 8 am departure from St. Croix that lands about 10:10 and a 3 pm return that lands about 5:10, so a same-day return gives you roughly five hours on St. Thomas. The crossing is about two hours, depending on sea conditions.

The operator's site lists a one-way fare of $85. Check-in closes 15 minutes before departure, no-shows are not refunded, and every passenger, even the youngest, must bring ID or birth papers. Look at qe4ferry.com the week you travel.

Cape Air links STX and STT in about 25 minutes, with small planes that fly several times daily. It is the option when you are connecting to a mainland flight at the other island's airport, or the seaplane is full. And once on St. Thomas, the Red Hook ferry takes 15 to 20 minutes over to St. John, roughly hourly through the day.

None of these crossings takes a passport. They are domestic hops, on whatever ID got you onto the plane (the ferry wants ID for children too). The British Virgin Islands are the exception, covered below.

A de Havilland Twin Otter on floats in flight
Seaborne's Twin Otter on floats crosses between the harbors in around 25 minutes. Photo: Leif Jørgensen (CC BY-SA 4.0)

A day on St. Thomas, starting at the villa

  1. Book the seaplane a few days ahead on seaborneairlines.com: the first departure out and a late-afternoon return, and confirm the baggage limit.
  2. Leave after sunrise for the 15 to 20 minute drive to town, where Prince Street has a small free lot facing the seaplane terminal.
  3. Check in with the same ID you flew to St. Croix with, and carry a day bag only, with mineral sunscreen and a swimsuit under your clothes.
  4. Twenty-five minutes over the water and you land in Charlotte Amalie harbor, a short walk from Fort Christian, the 99 Steps, the synagogue and Main Street.
  5. Spend the morning downtown, then taxi to Magens Bay (about $7 to enter, lifeguards, rentals) or ride up to the overlooks for the harbor view, then lunch in town or Frenchtown.
  6. Be back at the seaplane base well before your return. The flight home lands you in Christiansted in time for dinner on the boardwalk or sunset on the East End.

Day trips from St. Croix and the British Virgin Islands

Nobody says you have to pick just one. A week at a St. Croix villa with one day on St. Thomas is a common plan, and the seaplane is what makes it sensible: 25 minutes each way, an early flight out and a late one back, and a full day between them for the fort, the 99 Steps, the synagogue, Main Street and a swim at Magens Bay. The ferry version is cheaper and shorter: the QE IV's 8 am departure and 3 pm return give you about five hours in Charlotte Amalie, with two hours each way at sea.

St. John from St. Croix is possible and long. You fly or sail to Charlotte Amalie, take a taxi across St. Thomas to Red Hook, catch the roughly hourly ferry to Cruz Bay (about 15 to 20 minutes), and then a taxi to Trunk Bay or wherever you are headed, and you do all of it again in reverse in time for the last seaplane. Budget generously for the taxis and the waits.

It can be a very good day, and if St. John's park is a big reason for your trip, build in an overnight there.

Then there is the line on the water. All three islands fly the U.S. flag, so moving among them is domestic, with no customs or forms. Just east of St. John lies a foreign country, the British Virgin Islands, where every visitor, children included, needs a valid passport and goes through entry checks.

A BVI day is routine from the northern islands for anyone with a passport. From St. Croix it is not realistic in a day, because you would stack a seaplane, a taxi, an international ferry and two customs halls each way. Our passport guide covers the document rules for every case, including non-citizens and the departure check.

Who each island suits

St. Thomas

First-time Caribbean travelers who want everything within reach; anyone whose trip depends on a specific nonstop or on a short break, because daily flights from the Northeast, Texas, Florida and the Mid-Atlantic make a long weekend workable; shoppers; people who loved a cruise stop and want a week of it; resort people; and travelers who want St. John and the BVI within an hour.

St. John

Hikers, snorkelers on foot, campers, and national-park people in general; couples who want to hike to a beach and turn in early; anyone whose idea of a good day is Trunk Bay at 8 am before the ferries fill it. It suits travelers who do not mind that the island is small and that everything, including you, arrives by boat. It suits large groups less well, because flat land, parking and big houses are all scarce, and every outing begins with the ferry.

St. Croix

Families and multi-generation groups who want a single house with a kitchen and pool instead of six rooms; divers, because of the wall; history people, because of the two towns, the forts, the estates and Salt River; repeat Caribbean visitors who are done with ports; anyone who wants a car and a big island to learn over a week or two; and travelers who would rather see the island's own life than a version of it staged at the pier.

It suits winter travelers well, because the Saturday flights from Newark, Chicago, Charlotte and Atlanta fit a house rented Saturday to Saturday.

The mixed group, which is most groups, has an answer too: base on St. Croix, where the house and the beach and the quiet are, and send the shoppers and the city-lovers to St. Thomas for a day on the seaplane. It is the plan our guests use most.

Weighing St. Croix against a bigger name? We set it beside Puerto Rico and Punta Cana, and look at uncrowded Caribbean islands more broadly.

Easy mistakes when choosing an island

The first mistake is geographic: booking St. Thomas "to see St. Croix," or the other way round, as if they were a bridge apart. They are 40 miles of sea apart. Each is a base in its own right, and a day trip is a day trip, not a commute. Related: landing at the wrong airport. Flights sell to "the Virgin Islands," and STT and STX are two different islands; if you are staying on St. Croix, fly into STX, or plan on purpose to arrive at STT and take Cape Air or the seaplane across.

The second is assuming the ferry. The QE IV sails six days a week, but not on Tuesdays, so check the operator's site the week you travel, arrive 30 minutes early, and bring ID for every child. If your plans cannot bend, book the seaplane instead. Third: know that St. Croix goes to bed early. Its bars are good and few, and its towns are quiet by midnight.

Fourth, on the two northern islands, check the cruise calendar before you commit a day to Magens Bay or Trunk Bay; both are at their best on a light-ship morning and at their worst around noon on a four-ship day. Fifth, on St. Croix, remember you drive on the left, at up to 35 mph, and our driving guide covers the rest. Sixth, pack mineral sunscreen, because the USVI banned oxybenzone and similar ingredients in 2020. And last: the passport. If the BVI is on your list, bring it.

The villa from the air at nightfall, above its East End bay.
The villa from the air at nightfall, above its East End bay. Photo: The Cerulean

Why families and groups like the East End

Everything above is general. This part is specific, because it is the reason we built this site. Our villa, The Cerulean, sleeps twelve in five bedrooms, each with its own bath: four up at the main house, plus a cottage that has a loft bed, twenty steps off, which is the arrangement that lets grandparents, parents and teenagers share a holiday without sharing a wall.

In front of it is a beach with its own way into the water and a reef close offshore, and above the beach a pool and deck, an outdoor kitchen and grill, a fire pit terrace, and a chef's kitchen looking out to sea. The drive is gated. The house faces sunrise.

Out east the island is quiet and sunny: low hills and sea grape on the ridges, a string of bays along both shores, Point Udall at the tip for sunrise, and the Jack's and Isaac's bay trail about five minutes from the villa's gate. Christiansted, with its fort, its restaurants and the seaplane, is roughly 15 to 20 minutes west, and the airport is 35 to 40 minutes. East End marinas run Buck Island boats as well as the town docks, so the closest departures are near us. It is quiet even by St. Croix's standard.

For twelve people, that means one long table, a snorkel before breakfast and a seaplane 20 minutes away for the day anyone wants a city.

2008-01-27 Teague Bay Beach St. Croix USVI
Photo: Jpheym Jason P. Heym / Seascape Pool Center Inc. (CC BY-SA 3.0)
2008-01-27 Grapetree Bay St. Croix USVI
Photo: Jpheym Jason P. Heym / Seascape Pool Center Inc. (CC BY-SA 3.0)
East End, St Croix 00820, USVI - panoramio
Photo: Андрей Бобровский (CC BY 3.0)

Questions people ask

Which is better, St. Croix or St. Thomas?

That comes down to the trip. St. Croix suits a group looking for a house on the water, room to drive and explore, diving and two historic towns. St. Thomas suits a short break, shopping, a big resort and the most flights to choose from. We host guests on St. Croix, and for a week with family it is the island we would pick.

Which is the best U.S. Virgin Island to visit?

Go to St. John for the national park and its beaches. Choose St. Thomas for shops, restaurants and easy flights, and St. Croix for space, a house of your own, Buck Island and history. All three need no passport for U.S. citizens, so you can also see two of them in one trip.

Which island is better for a family trip?

You get more resorts and restaurants on St. Thomas, plus the most nonstops, and it is the gateway to St. John's park beaches. St. Croix is bigger and quieter, with beaches you rarely share, Buck Island's snorkel trail and more villa-style houses, which gives a large family room to cook and spread out. For a multi-generation group after a single house by the sea, St. Croix is the easier fit.

How far apart are St. Croix and St. Thomas?

About 40 miles of open sea. The northern two are a 15-to-20-minute ferry apart, and St. Croix sits alone to the south. That gap is why the islands feel so different. To cross it you take the seaplane (about 25 minutes), the ferry (about two hours) or a short scheduled flight.

Can you take a ferry from St. Croix to St. Thomas?

Yes. As posted on November 5, 2026, the QE IV ferry sails from Gallows Bay in Christiansted to Charlotte Amalie six days a week (no Tuesday sailing), leaving St. Croix at 8 am and returning from St. Thomas at 3 pm, about two hours each way, at $85 one way. Everyone, children included, needs ID or birth papers. Confirm the schedule on qe4ferry.com before you plan around it.

How long does the seaplane take?

About 25 minutes from one downtown to the other. Seaborne's Twin Otters leave Christiansted's waterfront and land at the Charlotte Amalie seaplane base. Bags are limited, so pack small. Cape Air also flies between the airports, in roughly the same time.

Which island has better beaches, St. Croix or St. Thomas?

St. Thomas has the more famous single beach in Magens Bay, a long crescent with lifeguards and a small entry fee, and St. John's Trunk Bay is the postcard of the whole territory. St. Croix offers more beaches and fewer people on them: Sandy Point, Cane Bay, Rainbow Beach, the East End bays, and Buck Island's Turtle Beach. If you want one perfect crowded beach, go north; if you want a different empty one every day, go south.

Is a passport needed to travel among the three islands?

No. They are all U.S. soil, so for an American the crossing is domestic and the ID from your flight is enough. The British Virgin Islands are different: they lie just east of St. John, and everyone going there, children too, needs a valid passport.

Which island has more nonstop flights, St. Croix or St. Thomas?

St. Thomas. Cyril E. King Airport is the busiest in the territory, with flights from more than a dozen mainland cities across the year. St. Croix's airport has Miami twice a day this winter, Atlanta and Charlotte through most of the week in high season, and Newark and Chicago on Saturdays. Many St. Croix visitors change planes in Miami or San Juan.

Can I visit St. Croix as a day trip from St. Thomas, or St. Thomas from St. Croix?

Yes, and the seaplane makes it easy: 25 minutes each way, with a whole day ashore between flights. St. John from St. Croix is possible but long, because you add a taxi across St. Thomas and the Cruz Bay ferry each way; treat it as an overnight if you can. The reverse trips work the same way, and the ferry, when it runs, gives you a cheaper but shorter day.

Planning your week from The Cerulean

If you have read this far and chosen St. Croix, the logistics are simple. Fly into STX (Miami all year; Charlotte, Atlanta, Chicago and Newark on the winter schedule described above; or a hop from San Juan or St. Thomas). Rent a car; you will want it, and our car rentals directory lists agencies that meet flights at the terminal. Drive east. Our concierge can stock the kitchen ahead of time, book a Buck Island boat from the East End, and arrange the seaplane day to St. Thomas for whoever in the group wants it, including a taxi at the Charlotte Amalie end if you would rather not walk.

A rhythm that works for a week: arrive Saturday and swim before dinner. On Sunday, catch sunrise at Point Udall, then stay by the pool. Monday, Christiansted in the morning and a Buck Island half day. Midweek, the shoppers fly to St. Thomas on the seaplane, the divers go to the wall at Cane Bay, and everyone else keeps the beach. A day for the west end and its beaches, a day for the rainforest and the estates, and the last day nowhere at all. That is a St. Croix week.

If you have chosen St. Thomas or St. John, come south on the seaplane for a day and see the island for yourself. It is 25 minutes, and it needs no passport.

The Cerulean's pool at sunset above the sea
The Cerulean

Bring the group to the quiet island

Room for twelve at The Cerulean, and a seaplane nearby for the St. Thomas day. The calendar shows live rates.

Sleeps 12 · 4.75 ★ on Airbnb · rates by season
The Cerulean villa at dawn above the sea
The Cerulean

Base the group on St. Croix

A long table, the reef, and the other two islands a day trip away.

Sleeps 12 · 4.75 ★ on Airbnb · rates by season