The island with the most room
Two Danish-built towns, Christiansted and Frederiksted, rum distilleries, Buck Island’s snorkel trail and a long East End of quiet bays. Most people rent a car and a house. Five U.S. cities have direct flights.

In the Caribbean, those two are the whole list for an American flying without a passport. Both are U.S. territories, and USA.gov confirms you can travel to them from the mainland with none. Every other island in the region is a foreign country or belongs to one.
| For U.S. citizens | Where in the Caribbean |
|---|---|
| No passport | The USVI (St. John, St. Croix and St. Thomas), plus Puerto Rico with Vieques and Culebra. |
| Passport | Every other island, from the Bahamas and Jamaica to Aruba, the Cayman Islands and Turks and Caicos. |
You still need ID at the airport. Anyone 18 or over shows a REAL ID license with its star, or something else from the TSA’s list. Younger travelers show nothing.
Two Danish-built towns, Christiansted and Frederiksted, rum distilleries, Buck Island’s snorkel trail and a long East End of quiet bays. Most people rent a car and a house. Five U.S. cities have direct flights.
Charlotte Amalie is the territory’s capital and a major cruise port, with the longest list of mainland flights in the territory. A seaplane connects it to St. Croix in about 25 minutes.
More than half of it is national park, and Trunk Bay’s beach has a marked snorkel trail. You get there by ferry after a flight to St. Thomas. Our three-island comparison sets all three side by side.
A large island with a capital city, and two small ones, Vieques and Culebra, a short hop east. We set it against St. Croix in St. Croix vs. Puerto Rico.
| Destination | Part of | What U.S. citizens need |
|---|---|---|
| The Bahamas | Independent | Passport valid at entry and for your whole stay |
| Jamaica | Independent | Passport valid at entry and exit, plus an online immigration and customs card before you arrive |
| Dominican Republic | Independent | Passport with six months left from your arrival date, plus a return ticket |
| Barbados | Independent | Passport valid at entry, plus proof you plan to leave |
| St. Lucia | Independent | Passport valid for your stay, plus an online travel form before you arrive |
| Antigua and Barbuda | Independent | Valid passport, plus a return or onward ticket |
| St. Kitts and Nevis | Independent | Passport, plus an online travel form before you arrive |
| Grenada | Independent | Passport with six months left from your arrival date |
| St. Vincent and the Grenadines | Independent | Valid passport, plus proof you plan to leave |
| Trinidad and Tobago | Independent | Passport with six months of validity |
| Aruba | Kingdom of the Netherlands | Passport valid for your stay, plus a $20 entry fee |
| Curaçao | Kingdom of the Netherlands | Passport valid for your stay, plus an arrival card |
| Sint Maarten | Kingdom of the Netherlands | Passport valid for your stay, an arrival card and a return ticket |
| Bonaire | The Netherlands | Passport valid for your stay, plus proof of onward travel and lodging |
| Cayman Islands | United Kingdom | Passport valid at entry and exit |
| Turks and Caicos | United Kingdom | Passport with three months left past your departure date |
| British Virgin Islands | United Kingdom | Passport valid at entry, plus a return or onward ticket |
| Anguilla | United Kingdom | Passport valid at entry; an online form if you enter through St. Maarten |
| St. Barthélemy | France | Passport with six months left from your arrival date |
| Guadeloupe and Martinique | France | Valid U.S. passport |
A cruise is the one way to reach foreign islands without a passport book, and only on some routes. CBP calls it closed-loop when a round trip starts and finishes at one American port, and then a U.S. citizen can re-enter with a birth certificate and a government photo ID. That covers only your return home. A port along the way can still want a passport, so ask the line about each stop.
The State Department still urges a passport book on anyone taking a cruise. Miss the ship or leave it early, and you would be flying home from a foreign airport, which takes a passport.
A passport card is cheaper and fits in a wallet. The State Department describes it as good for land and sea trips to Canada, Mexico, Bermuda and parts of the Caribbean, with no use on an international flight, so it won’t work for flying to Aruba or Jamaica. As TSA ID it works fine on a domestic route to St. Croix or San Juan.
CBP says children need their own passport to fly home to the U.S. from a foreign country, so a family of five to Jamaica needs five. On a domestic route, including those to San Juan and St. Thomas, the TSA asks no ID of anyone under 18. If you are bringing children, pack their birth certificates too, since the USVI tourism office tells people leaving to keep proof of citizenship on hand.
If your own passport has lapsed and your trip is soon, the U.S. islands are the easy answer. A REAL ID is all you need, and the TSA currently accepts expired ID, passports included, for up to two years past the date printed on it. Foreign islands ask for more: several in the table want six months left on the passport.
All of this applies to U.S. citizens. Everyone else follows the usual U.S. entry rules: your own passport, plus the visa, ESTA or green card your status calls for. The island’s visitor site, GoToStCroix, asks non-citizens to carry a passport and proof of immigration status.

We know one of these islands well, because we host guests here. St. Croix, the largest in the territory, is calmest at its far eastern tip: low hills, reefs close to shore and Point Udall at the very end.
Our villa there, The Cerulean, has five bedrooms on the ocean and room for twelve. If you are reading this because a grandparent or a child has no passport, everyone can still come.
For Americans, two places: Puerto Rico, with its smaller islands Vieques and Culebra, and the three main islands of the USVI. USA.gov lists both as territories you can visit with no passport.
Almost always. Flying anywhere in the region outside those two U.S. territories takes one, since every other island belongs to a foreign country. Each child needs their own for the flight back.
Not by air. The State Department wants a passport that lasts through your stay. People on a cruise may use another approved document, though the department recommends a passport for them too.
Sometimes. If you sail round trip from one U.S. port, CBP will take a birth certificate and photo ID when you come home. Stops along the way can ask for more, and leaving the ship early would mean flying home on a passport, so ask your cruise line.
Only by sea, and only for some islands. The State Department sets it up for land and sea trips to Canada, Mexico, Bermuda and parts of the Caribbean, and it can't be used on international flights. It does count as ID on domestic routes, such as San Juan or St. Croix.
Anyone 18 or older shows one item from the TSA's list. A license with the star is the usual choice, and a passport book or card also counts. Nobody under 18 has to show ID on these routes.
To the U.S. islands, yes. The TSA takes one up to two years out of date, and a REAL ID does the job anyway. Foreign islands expect a valid one, and some want months left on it, such as three months past departure for Turks and Caicos.
It depends on the week you want. St. Croix fits a group wanting one home by the water, two small Danish towns and quiet roads. Puerto Rico has San Juan and more flights. Our journal sets the two side by side.

Our East End villa on St. Croix has room for twelve. See the open weeks.